Meet the Fockers is a great example of how a film series can quickly lose its way. As the sequel to the classic 2000 comedy Meet the Parents, Fockers is desperate to recapture the magic. It has some inspired scenes and great acting. But it doesn’t remotely measure up because it forgets what made the original work so well in the first place.
Some time has passed since we last saw Ben Stiller’s nebbish, grating Gaylord, “Greg,” Focker. He is still engaged to Teri Polo’s long-suffering Pam and is now preparing to introduce his soon-to-be in-laws, Jack (Robert De Niro) and Dina (Blythe Danner) Byrnes, to his parents, Bernie and Roz (Dustin Hoffman and Barbra Streisand, respectively).
The Fockers live in Florida, but instead of flying together to meet them, Greg, Pam, Jack and Dina all pack themselves into Jack’s RV to head down to the Sunshine State. They also bring along little Jack Byrnes, the one-year-old son of Debbie, Pam’s sister. Unlike the stuffed-shirt, WASPy Byrnes, Bernie and Roz are free-wheeling former hippies and horny perverts for one another.
Sharp contrast like this can often produce a great comedy. Fockers fails to recapture the lightning in a bottle that was Parents. The original film of the series works so well because of how restrained it is. It was basically a semi-realistic comedy of manners that drew its strength from comedic underplay and finely detailed characters. With Fockers, that restraint goes out the window.
A broader, bawdier affair, Fockers often feels like it takes place in a different universe from Parents. Sex and body humor bits are plentiful, despite the first film not really going there. Characters also often feel like cartoons. In Parents, De Niro’s Jack was comically paranoid and paternalistic. But as a CIA spook wary of his daughter’s new (and somewhat off-putting) partner, it still contained an internal logic. His most extreme actions (such as the famous polygraph scene) also still felt rooted to the realm of the possible.
The Jack we see in Fockers has none of this gravity. His suspicion of Greg makes less sense because they now have an established relationship. Jack’s actions also go far beyond something like a lie detector test, which was hyper-realistic but could still conceivably happen. With Fockers, on the other hand, Jack strays into borderline psychopath territory. His behavior is often not only brutish and intimidating but sometimes utterly criminal.
Fockers’ tonal swerve isn’t a problem inherently. Films like Thor: Ragnarok demonstrate how a series can go in a different direction and be better for it. That’s not the case with Fockers. The film’s more bombastic quality is often more grating than funny. Moments meant to elicit big laughs routinely fall flat. The clearest example is a big pratfall that involves foreskin and fondue. While the joke may have hit better in 2004, I wanted to retch more than ROFL. The lack of realistic characters means there is also often nothing to balance out the buffoonery.
If there is a saving grace, it’s that Fockers has three of the 20th century’s most wonderful actors in its supporting cast. All of them deliver at times despite the film’s many limitations. De Niro’s gift for hilariously grumpy facial expressions is on full display. Streisand is also a joy to watch, digging into her loving and lascivious character with little vanity.
The film’s absolute best moments, however, belong to Hoffman. Despite having been outed as a real-life scumbag and possible sex criminal in recent years, there is no denying how good this very bad man is at acting. Like De Niro in Meet the Parents, Hoffman’s work in Fockers is a revelation and a testament to his range as an actor.
His Bernie is both an enlightened, sensitive soul who shuns traditional masculinity and also a dementedly competitive monster. The football scene where he tackles De Niro, flips him completely over his head and sends him crashing to earth like a sack of potatoes had me laughing harder than I have at any movie all year. I would say the same for when Bernie attempts to fight Jack and winds up roundhouse kicking Greg in the face instead.
He is also almost singlehandedly responsible for the film’s few stray moments of authenticity and heart. One example is when Bernard is showing off Greg’s many participation trophies to the Byrnes. Beaming, he says of his son, “He’s my champion.” It’s a small, blink-and-you’ll-miss-it moment, but Hoffman delivers it with such warmth, love and sincerity that I was honestly moved. It’s a rare point in Fockers where it feels like we are watching real people.
But scenes like these are too few and far between. While Fockers isn’t utterly devoid of laughs or emotion, it’s pretty damn close. In part, that has to do with it jettisoning a lot of what worked before for the series. Of course, you kind of have to admire a sequel that isn’t just a slavish recreation of what came before and veers off on its own path. You just wish that Fockers’ decision to do so would have led somewhere more worthwhile.